How Food Reformulation Affects Consumer Expectations and Brand Loyalty

How Food Reformulation Affects Consumer Expectations and Brand Loyalty

By Erin Russeck, Chief Research Officer, AMC Global

Key takeaways:

  • Longtime buyers judge a reformulated product against the original they know. A version that wins with new shoppers can still lose your core customers, so test both groups.
  • Consumers will notice small changes to taste, texture, color, or scent before reading the label. Research on which qualities matter most shows where you have room to adjust.
  • Follow up with real purchasers shortly after purchase and again as they keep using the product to determine whether the new formula drives repeat buys.

Consumers may not remember every ingredient in their favorite snack, but they know exactly how it’s supposed to taste… the crunch, the sweetness, the texture, and even the color are all part of an experience they’ve come to know by heart. Change one of those familiar characteristics, and people may notice long before they read the updated ingredient label.

Food manufacturers have a lot of reasons to revisit established recipes right now, with a bevy of new ingredient requirements, nutritional priorities, and changing consumer preferences prompting updates to products that may have been on store shelves for decades. In addition to finding replacement ingredients when that is needed, manufacturers also have to understand how those changes might affect the taste, texture, and other qualities that consumers have come to expect.

Recently, Perfetti Van Melle announced plans to transition more than 650 U.S. products, including Airheads, Mentos Gum, and Trident, to non-artificial colors. As food manufacturers move toward natural colors, understanding which product qualities consumers value most, and how much change they’re willing to accept, can help inform reformulation decisions before updated products reach the market.

What makes a product familiar?

People develop strong preferences for the foods they buy regularly, right down to the way a favorite cracker breaks when they bite into it, the thickness of a pasta sauce or the texture of a frozen meal. Even subtle changes to these familiar qualities can mark a noticeable difference for consumers.

When manufacturers change an ingredient, the effects can reach into several aspects of that experience, such as a reduction in sodium that alters flavor or a replacement color that affects appearance. Other substitutions or reformulations can influence texture, scent, or how a product behaves during preparation. Consumers might not be able to pinpoint what’s different, but they sure can tell when something isn’t quite the way they remember it!

Market research with existing purchasers can help manufacturers identify which product characteristics matter most and how consumers respond to changes in formulation. Foundational research can also help brands understand what better-for-you means to consumers, which ingredients signal health and simplicity, and whether an established brand has the credibility to introduce healthier options. Testing alternatives can reveal which changes could go largely unnoticed, which ones might affect enjoymen,t and where there might be flexibility to adjust a recipe while preserving the qualities that keep people buying it.

The loyal customer factor

Established products have an advantage in the marketplace because consumers already know what they’re getting, but that familiarity also means longtime purchasers may be especially sensitive to changes. For example, if a snack food has been reformulated to remove an ingredient, someone trying the product for the first time may enjoy it and rate it highly. A consumer who has purchased the original version for years, however, may notice a difference immediately and judge the new product against the one they’ve always known. Consumer studies among both groups can help manufacturers understand how a revised formulation might perform with new buyers while also assessing the potential response from existing customers.

These findings can be especially useful when product developers are choosing among several formulation alternatives. A version that appeals to a broad group of category consumers may not be the one that best preserves the experience loyal purchasers expect, and understanding those differences can inform decisions about formulation, positioning, and how changes are communicated.

How reformulated products perform in real life

Understanding how consumers respond to a reformulated product in their own homes can provide valuable information that isn’t always apparent during development. Preparation methods, storage conditions, and repeated use can all influence satisfaction, particularly when consumers are comparing a revised product with one they’ve purchased for years.

Market research with verified purchasers who have independently selected and purchased a product can help manufacturers understand how a new formulation performs in everyday use. Gathering feedback shortly after purchase and following up as consumers continue using the product can reveal unexpected issues, changes in satisfaction, and whether the revised formulation is encouraging repeat purchases. These insights can help manufacturers identify opportunities for further improvements and understand how changes to established products are being received in the market.

For food brands with established products, reformulation decisions can carry the weight of long-time consumer familiarity. Understanding what people already appreciate about a product, how they respond to changes over time, and whether they’re willing to keep buying it can help manufacturers protect the relationships they’ve spent years building.

Erin Russeck is chief research officer at AMC Global, bringing more than 20 years of experience in consumer packaged goods and consumer healthcare research. She specializes in developing custom research strategies that help brands understand consumer behavior, evaluate products, and make informed business decisions. Erin leads research initiatives across product development and innovation, with a focus on translating consumer insights into actionable recommendations for brands. 

Facebook
X
LinkedIn
Email
WhatsApp