Soil Association to withdraw logo from organic farmed salmon. The Soil Association has decided to withdraw from setting standards for organic salmon after an extensive review found that environmental and welfare outcomes were not meeting its “high bar”.
The charity, which has been developing and setting standards for organic salmon farming for more than two decades, has been reviewing its involvement for the last two years.
This review has concluded that Soil Association standards have sparked positive change across the whole salmon farming industry, and that further improvement could be possible.
However, there was a lack of evidence that the standards were delivering good enough animal welfare and environmental outcomes, or that this could change fast enough, the charity says.
Soil Association Chief Executive Helen Browning said:
“The mission behind the Soil Association and its standards is to develop and support farming systems that care for the natural world and farmed animals.
“When we started working on salmon 20 years ago, we had an aspiration for an aquaculture system that could deliver the principles of organic production in the sea. We envisioned a multi-trophic, enriched environment which could provide the resources for a good life for salmon, with minimal negative impact on other species. However, progress along these lines has been negligible. While our standards ensure lower stocking rates and prohibit the most damaging chemical treatments, the evidence suggests that welfare and environmental outcomes are not sufficient for us to continue.
“Furthermore, new welfare challenges like jellyfish blooms are emerging due to warming seas. The salmon industry is dynamic and profitable and may well be able to innovate to deal with these emerging challenges. But we were not confident that the issues were likely to be resolved within a suitable timeframe through our standards. There is a bigger research and development piece needed here which, as a charity, it is not our role to lead.
“While no farming system is perfect, the Soil Association standards set a high bar. When consumers see our logo on pack, they should be confident that organic principles are being safeguarded to the highest level possible within the constraints of a commercially viable system. This means being prepared to ask difficult questions and this is a case where we must act on the evidence when we believe we can no longer provide that assurance.”
Findings from the review
The review heard from producers, aquaculture experts, scientists, policymakers, animal welfare experts, campaigners and others.
It considered a broad range of evidence relating to salmon welfare, environmental performance and the effectiveness of Soil Association standards in delivering good outcomes.
Key findings include:
- Soil Association standards have led to improvements in organic and non-organic salmon farming. They led to better practices being rolled out across the entire industry, including pre-slaughter stunning and innovative approaches to net cleaning that avoid the use of chemical anti-foulants.
- Organic sites perform well on veterinary treatments, with the most harmful treatments banned and minimal use of the treatments which are permitted, including Deltamethrin, in the last two years.
- Analysis of publicly available data on mortality and sea lice outbreaks showed high mortality rates, which were not significantly better than non-organic sites in recent years. There were also concerns around preventing suffering as it is difficult to treat or euthanise individual fish.
- It also found that mortality events are often outside of the control of the sector with rising water temperatures leading to parasite outbreaks and disease. There was a lack of evidence and therefore confidence that this was likely to change within a tenable timeframe.
- There was also concern around feed sustainability, as organic standards require producers to feed salmon as natural a diet as possible. The Soil Association was concerned this was resulting in too much reliance on wild fish stocks and the review had an ambition to progress stricter standards to prioritise marine by-products and trimmings. But challenges around these products led to a lack of confidence this was likely to be resolved fast enough.
Next steps for organic salmon
The Soil Association will now work with the industry to agree a timeline for withdrawal of its logo. Further updates will follow over the coming weeks and months.
Browning added:
“We recognise the commitment, expertise and significant efforts made by producers, processors and others across the sector to meet our standards and seek progress. We hope that work will continue and are grateful to the sector for collaborating with us constructively through this review.”
More information on the review, its findings and the process followed is available at: www.soilassociation.org/salmonreview
Image: The Soil Association



