Evaluating Aquaculture on an Even Playing Field

Evaluating Aquaculture on an Even Playing Field

Evaluating aquaculture on an even playing field. The following article was co-authored by Innovasea senior leaders Jean Turpin and Marc Turano and outlines the company’s perspective on this complex and important issue.

Aquaculture has a long history of being closely scrutinised. New reporting is once again questioning its sustainability, this time with much of the focus on fishmeal. Questions surrounding labour practices, pollution, food security, and production management deserve our attention. But the practices of a single subsector at one point of the value chain should not define an entire global industry.

Aquaculture is exceptionally diverse, accounting for more than half of the seafood we eat. Salmon is a major component of that, but it is far from the only species. Today, fish farming extends well beyond traditional cold-water fjords into waters once deemed impossible to farm. From warm-water environments to remote offshore locations, responsible aquaculture is producing high-quality protein, creating opportunities for coastal communities and doing so with a commitment to preserving the waters and ecosystems that make it possible.

Basing assumptions about an entire industry on one component, particularly when relying on outdated information, is incredibly misleading. Imagine judging all agriculture based on the practices used to produce a single crop in a single location. At best, this oversimplifies a complex chain and discredits the progress that’s been made.

With this context in mind, let’s explore what responsible aquaculture looks like today.

The realities of fishmeal and feeding

Let’s get one thing out of the way: fish farming is not without impact. But no form of production at scale is. Compared with alternatives, farmed fish remains one of the most efficient and environmentally responsible ways to produce animal protein.

Fishmeal has long been a point of contention, but modern feed looks very different than it did decades ago. Future Feeds found that in 1990, the average Norwegian salmon diet contained 65% fishmeal and 24% fish oil. By 2019, those shares had fallen to 13% and 11%, respectively.

That progress extends beyond salmon. Researchers at the Universitat Politècnica de València and the University of Bologna have shown sea bass and sea bream can be fed a similar fishmeal and oil makeup, and in some cases even less, without compromising growth.

Now, a skeptic would say fish are still used to produce feed and, for now, that’s true. However, the Food and Agriculture Organiation (FAO) states that fishmeal is often produced from low-value fish or fish-processing by-products.

That’s not to say every fish used for fishmeal would otherwise go uneaten, but the reality is more nuanced than aquaculture simply robbing Peter to pay Paul.

Taking it one step further, consider how efficiently farmed fish convert feed into protein.

One of aquaculture’s most important metrics is feed conversion ratio (FCR), which measures how much feed is needed to produce a pound of fish. Because feed is also a major expense, farmers have a strong incentive to keep FCR as low as possible, increasingly using technology and data to reduce waste.

Salmon producers consistently achieve FCRs close to 1. Mowi and SalMar, for example, reported 1.3 and 1.13, respectively. For warm water species, yellowtail and totoaba typically have an FCR of 1.6. Meanwhile, sea bass and sea bream are typically higher, around 2.0, rising to as high as 3.0 during winter and spawning periods.

Of course, wild-caught fish need to eat too. According to research from the University of California’s Sea Grant Extension Programme, wild salmon has an FCR of roughly 10:1.

Given the makeup of modern feed, even at the higher FCRs, fish farms produce considerably more marine-based protein than they use.

Expanding on what’s possible

Aquaculture has long since moved beyond the waters where it got its start. Today, farms operate around the world in incredibly diverse environments. From the extreme heat of the Red Sea to the deep, rough waters off Panama, advances in fully submersible pen technology have opened new frontiers for responsible fish farming.

Importantly, we’re also beginning to understand what these farms mean for the surrounding environment, and the data tells an exciting story.

Research increasingly shows that when properly sited, sea-based aquaculture can be an efficient and environmentally responsible way to produce fish. A six-year study of Open Blue, a commercial cobia farm, found no significant differences in water quality in or around the farm.

The findings are another proof point that aquaculture can help address food insecurities while still protecting the environments it depends on.

A broader impact

As aquaculture continues to grow, so does its potential to make a positive impact beyond food production.

Santomar, based in La Paz, Baja California Sur, offers a powerful example of what this can look like.

Using advanced, fully submersible pens, the farm raises totoaba and Pacific red snapper in the deep waters of the Sea of Cortez. Designed around the unique needs of these species and supported by advanced aquaculture technology, these systems provide a responsible way to produce fish that have historically faced significant pressure in the wild.

What’s more, each year Santomar’s Totoabas a la Mar program releases more than 40,000 juveniles back into the Sea of Cortez to help repopulate a species once on the brink of extinction. With more than 300,000 endangered totoaba returned to the sea, Santomar is offering high-quality protein today, while also taking an active role in ensuring the long-term success of that species.

An industry of innovation

Fish farming has a rich history of innovation. Each year, farms introduce new technologies to streamline operations, improve fish health and welfare, and reduce their environmental impact.

SINTEF, one of Europe’s largest independent research organisations, reported that the carbon footprint of Norwegian farmed salmon has fallen by approximately 10% since 2017. Today, salmon has a lower carbon footprint than chicken, pork, and beef.

At Innovasea, we’re proud to play a small role in this ongoing transformation. Our technology is helping advance data-driven, precision aquaculture, while our fully submersible pens allow farmers to make use of the entire water column.

Together, we’re enabling established farms to fine-tune their operations while opening new opportunities for emerging sites. It’s all part of our mission to deliver (re) generative aquaculture solutions that bring sustainability, profitability, and environmental stewardship together.

The bottom line: Give aquaculture a fair fight

Aquaculture is not perfect. There are still many areas where we can improve, challenges we need to address, and practices that deserve to be re-examined.

We are not saying aquaculture shouldn’t have to face tough questions. We are simply asking that the industry, and the more than 22 million people who work within it, be judged by today’s facts and measured fairly against the alternatives. Aquaculture is the only valid method to increase the supply of seafood for a growing world.

That’s how we have a meaningful conversation about its shortcomings, its progress, and what should come next.

Image by LTapsaH from Pixabay

Facebook
X
LinkedIn
Email
WhatsApp